Rubber Soled Wading Boots…Better Than Felt?
The latest hype in the fly fishing industry is the wading boot companies trying to replace the perfected felt soles with untested rubber soles. The theory behind banning felt-bottomed boots seems worthwhile (check out this article for more info on that), yet the replacement for felt seems forced upon us by the boot companies. Every wading boot company has created a rubber-bottomed sole that they think will get you, the angler, from point A to point B without falling on your you-know-what. Not one boot company uses the same rubber sole, yet every wading boot company just 2 years ago used the exact same felt on the bottom of their wading boots. The real question is, will any rubber-soled boots be able to hold their own against felt-soled boots.
We all know that felt works. Anytime you have a stream with rounded, moss-covered, slimy rocks, you need felt. Other than that felt does have its drawbacks. Felt wears out fairly quickly, it’s slippery on steep grassy banks and snow sticks to the felt bottoms. To top things off, felt doesn’t dry, therefore, aquatic what-evers can be carried from one river to the next via your damp felt-soled wading boots.
Rubber soled wading boots in theory would be great. Rubber dries out quickly, therefore, aquatic hitchhikers are less likely to be carried from one river to the next. Rubber soles are nice to hike in, on the way to the river, along the banks, down grassy steep banks, and rubber doesn’t hold onto snow like felt. This we know. We walk around on rubber soled shoes all the time. The real problem is those slimy round rocks found in most of our rivers. How will rubber-bottomed wading boots hold up in those environments?
After checking out all the different rubber soled wading boots out there, I decided on Dan Bailey’s Eco-Grip Wading Boots. The Eco-Grip boot seems well built, with beefy stitches, toe guards, and a nice boxy fit, definitely not on the narrow side. The rubber sole is what I really liked about these boots. The tread bottom has lots of edges and lots of surface area, like what you look for in good snow tires. Edges, surface-area, and grippy-soft rubber.
I’ve worn these boots on two different rivers with the dreaded rounded, slimy rocks. All I can say is wow. These boots seem like they grip better than felt in almost every circumstance. Hiking, steep grassy banks, and slime covered round river rocks. The rubber soles really amaze me. After walking in felt soles around 100-150 days a year for the last 15 years, I’m upset the boot companies didn’t go to rubber soles earlier on.
I’ve only worn the boots a few times now, but I am really impressed with their grip on slimy rocks. I’ll keep you posted on how the boots hold up, or if I find some places where felt is still superior to rubber-soled boots. Let me know what you think about these boots or other brands of rubber bottomed wading boots.
Early Spring Fly Fishing
Early spring fly fishing, or as we call it here in Montana, late winter fly fishing, is not for everyone. You pretty much look for a break in the cold, wintery weather, say temps above freezing, and no wind…good luck. Starting in Feb. we begin to see signs of insect life on our local rivers. If there are insects moving around, figure there are fish that haven’t eaten much all winter looking for a meal, even if it’s a bug the size of a pin head like a midge. Midges show up in good numbers towards the end of Feb. and early March, and then the Baetis show up in early April. If you can handle the cold, early spring can offer some fantastic fishing opportunities.
Deep nymph fishing, or indicator fishing is the ticket in the slower, deeper sections of the river when there are no insects crawling around or hatching. I like to tie on two nymphs below an indicator with some split shot. First, I tie on a big attractor nymph size 8-12, like a copper john, then a little midge imitation size 14-20, like a black zebra midge. Once the water temps warm up a bit, the hatches increase in intensity and duration. The fish will start to move out of the deeper wintering holes, and get closer to the source of the hatch. Riffle corners will be loaded with fish eating both on the surface and sub-surface. A dry- dropper is killer in these situations, as is a single dry on those perfectly calm days. When fishing a dry dropper, I like to fish a high-vis Baetis pattern, like a size 14-18 olive parachute hare’s ear. For a dropper, add 12 inches of 5x tied to the bend of your dry fly hook with a beadhead midge of choice, like a size 18 zebra midge. This combo will get it done about 90% of the time if fish are looking for midges or Baetis in calmer water. In flat, shallow water, a single dry might be the way to go since the splash or plop of a beadhead nymph could spook that steadily rising trout. Once the Baetis start hatching, usually in late March, or early April, the dry dropper is still the preferred method.
Observation and stealth is key in early spring fishing when the trout have moved out of the deeper water and are keyed in on midge or Baetis activity. The fish are not real spooky this time of year, instead, you will notice that the midging trout want to eat those small insects without wasting any energy. So look for fish in shallow, slow water next to good holding water. There are many days where I’ll never get my boots wet because I recognized that the fish were feeding just inches off the the bank, lazily sipping midges off the surface of the water. If the fish are in just inches of water, use a dry fly of choice, like a size 18 Griffith’s Gnat, or Baetis pattern of choice if the blue-winged olives are hatching. Look around the river and at different types of water. The fish seem to pod up this time of year, and all eat in certain types of water. Look for rising active fish in riffle corners, slower current seams and boulder seams, wind protected banks, and the edges of tailouts. If you see one active fish, there should be others close by.
I think the observation game is my favorite part of early spring fly fishing. It’s more of a sneak-and-destroy type of fishing. Small flies, low gin-clear water, and happy fish are what you’ll get if you play your cards right. This is the best time of year to be able to catch some nice trout inches off the bank in the middle of the afternoon with dry flies. Once the weather warms up and the not so die-hard, less than hard core, smart fisherman start trampling up and down the bank, wading out in knee deep water (purely out of habit), slapping the water with giant bobbers, pushing those happy bank feeding fish out to depths unknown… where was I…
Anyways, grab those gloves, a couple pairs of thick wool socks, long-johns, a thick fleece sweater, jacket and your beanie and go wet a line. By the way, put a little Ginks on those guides before you go out, this helps slow down the process of your guides freezing when that wind does decide to pick up right in the middle of the best midge hatch of the year. Let me know how it goes. Hope to see you out there, just not on my river!
Yellowstone River
As you can see from the photo, we still have snow on the ground in downtown Livingston, MT and it is snowing as I write. Current snow pack for the Yellowstone River drainage is sitting at 75% of normal as of Feb. 4, 2010. Not to worry though, since the last couple of springs have been very wet. Forecast is calling for some more snow in the coming weeks with mild temps – daytime highs in the mid 20′s -mid 30′s.
Fishing should start to pick up on the Yellowstone and surrounding rivers towards the end of February with the fish eating midges, both dries and nymphs. Great time of year to be fishing… hungry fish and very few fisherman. So get out there if you can!
Online Fly Fishing Magazines
No longer do you have to go to your local bookstore, library, or fly shop to get your fish porn fix. Check out Catch Magazine and This Is Fly. These are two online magazines I have been looking at that offer fly fishing related photos and short videos. Catch Magazine has some incredible imagery along with some photography advice to improve your own photos.
Are there any others you can suggest? Am I missing out on something amazing that I just have to see? Please share your favorites with all of us. Have you already seen the two that I mentioned? What do you think about them?
The Beauty of Foam Hoppers

Sanchez foam wing hopper
Where do I even begin…
Livingston, Montana is a great place to fish hoppers late in the season. Being a fishing guide and avid fisherman myself I have had many opportunities to try out every kind of hopper imaginable. I love tying flies and coming up with my own variations on tried -and-true patterns. Every summer I try to outdo the last with a better hopper. When talking about foam hoppers what it eventually boils down to is that they are virtually unsinkable, fun to tie, and most importantly, from time to time fish mistake them for the real thing!
I’ve had fish eat tan, yellow, brown, black, green, goldenrod, peach, pink, and purple, yes pink and purple, foam hoppers. Almost every color of buoyant craft foam available from either fly shops or craft stores, has wound up on one of my foam hoppers. Add to that the availability of leg material in small, medium, large, round, flat, barred, with or without glitter, etc… in every color you can imagine, you start seeing the endless possibilities of foam and rubber.
Hoppers have come a long way from the timeless deer hair creations, including Joe’s hopper, Dave’s hopper, and the fly that may have started the synthetic craze, the Madam-X with those silly white rubber legs. Hoppers don’t have white legs, but for some reason, white rubber legs drive trout nuts. I can’t even count the number of trout I’ve fooled on white rubber legged flies like the Turk’s Tarantula, Madame-X, Sanchez Convertible series of flies, bitch creeks and yuk bugs. Sinking or floating, white rubber legs, or any colored rubber legs, just attract fish. Combine the floating qualities of foam, plus rubber legs to a hook, what you get are fish.
Foam floats, rubber legs wiggle. Fish love it. Enough said
What do you think? Do you enjoy fishing with foam hoppers as much as I do or do you refuse to fish with foam? What are some of your favorite patterns and most successful colors?






























































































































